50mm Lenses for Nikon Full Frame: Five Primes Compared

One of my first video blog posts, in which I go through all of my 50mm lenses and the different jobs and needs I use each of them for.
Used on full-frame cameras.

Silver Nikon camera with five 50mm lenses lined up on a white table

Overview

Key facts

  • In a video blog post (in Latvian), Andrejs Zavadskis compares the five 50mm lenses he owns for full-frame Nikon cameras and shows test shots from each.
  • Top score, 9, went to the Sigma 50mm f/1.4 DG HSM Art for its image quality, despite its bulk, 815 g weight and price.
  • The Nikon AF-S 50mm f/1.4G got 8 and the f/1.4D 7.5, while the f/1.8G Special Edition and the 50mm f/1.2 AIS got 7 each.
  • In dim light or in the studio, the Sigma missed focus more often than the Nikon lenses did.
  • For studio use he recommends the less expensive Nikon 50mm f/1.8G rather than a 1.4 model.

Video Review



How I Tested

I put every one of these lenses through a test. With each lens, wherever it allowed it, I shot the same frame at f/1.2, f/1.4, f/1.8 or f/2.0 and f/2.8, plus two frames at the widest aperture: one with the focus set to infinity and a final one at the closest focusing distance (minimum focus distance).
The original, unedited JPG files of all the pictures are available to download

The Lenses

Sigma 50mm f/1.4 DG HSM Art lens for Nikon F Sigma 50mm f/1.4 DG HSM Art Lens for Nikon F (750 EUR)
Size 85.4 x 99.9 mm
Weight 815g
Aperture blades: 9, rounded
Filter size 77mm
Minimum focus distance 40 cm

+ Superb quality at every aperture; at 1.4 it outperforms all my other lenses,
minimal aberrations, filter size, the shortest minimum focus distance of the group

- big, heavy, expensive, soft bokeh, long-term durability is an open question,
slightly less precise than the camera maker's own lenses

Rating: 9
f/1.4 f/2.0 f/2.8 f/1.4 ∞ f/1.4 40 cm
Sigma 50mm f/1.4 Art test shot at f/1.4 Sigma 50mm f/1.4 Art test shot at f/2.0 Sigma 50mm f/1.4 Art test shot at f/2.8 Sigma 50mm f/1.4 Art test shot at f/1.4 focused at infinity Sigma 50mm f/1.4 Art test shot at f/1.4 at the 40 cm minimum focus distance
Nikon AF-S Nikkor 50mm f/1.4G lens Nikon AF-S Nikkor 50mm f/1.4G Autofocus Lens (350 EUR)
Size 73.7 x 53.3 mm
Weight 281g
Aperture blades: 9
Filter size 58mm
Minimum focus distance 45.72 cm

+ Fast, good quality, small, light.

- Rather pricey, weak quality at f/1.4

Rating: 8

f/1.4 f/2.0 f/2.8 f/1.4 ∞ f/1.4 46 cm
Nikon AF-S 50mm f/1.4G test shot at f/1.4 Nikon AF-S 50mm f/1.4G test shot at f/2.0 Nikon AF-S 50mm f/1.4G test shot at f/2.8 Nikon AF-S 50mm f/1.4G test shot at f/1.4 focused at infinity Nikon AF-S 50mm f/1.4G test shot at f/1.4 at the 46 cm minimum focus distance
Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 50mm f/1.8G Special Edition lens Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 50mm f/1.8G Special Edition Lens (180 EUR)
Size 73 x 52.5 mm
Weight 190g
Aperture blades: 7
Filter size 58mm
Minimum focus distance 45 cm

+ Small, light, cheap, good quality at higher f-numbers

- Not a 1.4

Rating: 7
f/1.8 f/2.0 f/2.8 f/1.8 ∞ f/1.8 45 cm
Nikon AF-S 50mm f/1.8G test shot at f/1.8 Nikon AF-S 50mm f/1.8G test shot at f/2.0 Nikon AF-S 50mm f/1.8G test shot at f/2.8 Nikon AF-S 50mm f/1.8G test shot at f/1.8 focused at infinity Nikon AF-S 50mm f/1.8G test shot at f/1.8 at the 45 cm minimum focus distance
Nikon AF Nikkor 50mm f/1.4D lens Nikon AF Nikkor 50mm f/1.4D Autofocus Lens (280 EUR)
Size 63.5 x 43.2 mm
Weight 230g
Aperture blades: 7
Filter size 52mm
Minimum focus distance 45.72 cm

+ Small, light, the fastest to focus on high-end bodies

- Counts as the previous generation

Rating: 7.5
f/1.4 f/2.0 f/2.8 f/1.4 ∞ f/1.4 46 cm
Nikon AF 50mm f/1.4D test shot at f/1.4 Nikon AF 50mm f/1.4D test shot at f/2.0 Nikon AF 50mm f/1.4D test shot at f/2.8 Nikon AF 50mm f/1.4D test shot at f/1.4 focused at infinity Nikon AF 50mm f/1.4D test shot at f/1.4 at the 46 cm minimum focus distance
Nikon NIKKOR 50mm f/1.2 AIS manual focus lens Nikon NIKKOR 50mm f/1.2 AIS Manual Focus Lens (600 EUR)
Size 68.6 x 48.3 mm
Weight 360g
Aperture blades: 9
Filter size 52mm
Minimum focus distance 49.99 cm

+ Rugged, long-lasting, the brightest of the Nikons, beautiful and striking bokeh

- Weak quality at f/1.2 and f/1.4, manual focus

Rating: 7
f/1.2 f/1.4 f/2.0 f/2.8 f/1.2 ∞ f/1.2 50 cm
Nikon 50mm f/1.2 AIS test shot at f/1.2 Nikon 50mm f/1.2 AIS test shot at f/1.4 Nikon 50mm f/1.2 AIS test shot at f/2.0 Nikon 50mm f/1.2 AIS test shot at f/2.8 Nikon 50mm f/1.2 AIS test shot at f/1.2 focused at infinity Nikon 50mm f/1.2 AIS test shot at f/1.2 at the 50 cm minimum focus distance

The Sigma Art

The Sigma 50mm f/1.4 DG HSM Art really is a pleasure to use, but it has its drawbacks. When I bought the Sigma 35mm F1.4 DG HSM Art, I was delighted that it turned out small and compact after all. Comparing the 35mm lenses, the Sigma and the Nikon are almost the same size. Without the lens hood it is fairly compact and good-looking. Unpacking the Sigma 50mm was a bit of a shock. The lens is 3 times heavier and 2 times bigger than the AF-S Nikkor 50mm f/1.4G. I bought it so that I could shoot advertising work with a Nikon D800e and still use it at 1.4 or 2.0. For my everyday needs, though, I don't want to lug it around, because of its size and weight. The design surprised me as well: without the hood the lens looks unfinished and a little clumsy. The SIGMA 35mm F1.4 DG HSM Art, by contrast, looks very good without a hood.
Now, autofocus. In good light the Sigma Art and the Nikon G-series lenses perform much the same. On expensive cameras the Nikon D series will focus faster. In dark conditions or in the studio, however, the Sigma makes more autofocus errors than the Nikon lenses. Even the AF-S NIKKOR 50mm f/1.8G focuses more accurately in poor light.
A great many other Sigma lenses that broke have left a big black mark on the Sigma brand. I have had a bitter experience with Sigma myself, after which I promised myself never to buy a Sigma again. I broke that promise when the Sigma 35mm f/1.4 DG HSM Art came out, since it costs half as much as the Nikon 35mm f/1.4; the Sigma 50mm f/1.4, unfortunately, costs twice as much as the Nikon 50mm f/1.4 G. So far, service centres and the internet have nothing to say about how reliable the Sigma Art series is. Let's hope Sigma wants to change its image and release lenses that are not just optically excellent but also durable and long-lasting.
Every brand's lenses also have their own particular colour tint and rendering, and Sigma is no exception. Sigma's colours are slightly different from those of Nikon lenses. I can't call them worse or better; it is more a matter of taste. The colour difference is minimal, but after a while you can easily tell whether a picture was taken with a Nikon or a Sigma lens.

The f/1.8 Option: D Versus G

I couldn't get hold of the AF Nikon 50mm f/1.8 D for this test, but the DXO test shows that it is practically identical to the new G-series 1.8. The main difference is that a D-series lens is focused by the camera through a special screw. In other words, the autofocus motor sits in the camera body and drives the lens's focusing through this screw. The cheapest SLRs have no such screw, so no D-series lens is suitable for them. On the other hand, the more expensive the camera, the more powerful and faster this in-body motor is, and on professional cameras D-series lenses work very quickly. Looking through this test, I concluded that the D-series lens has crisp bokeh, exactly the kind I like, so the D series is also worth considering if your camera supports it. The Nikon D series costs roughly 80 EUR less than the new G series.

DxOMark scores of the Nikon AF-S 50mm f/1.8G and AF 50mm f/1.8D tested on a Nikon D800E

Conclusions

The DXO tests show that the f/1.4 G and D versions are almost identical. The key difference lies in how they are built and in the autofocus: as I mentioned, the AF speed and accuracy of the D version depend on how expensive the camera is. The 1.8 G version, on the other hand, is a very good alternative, and I especially recommend it if you work in a studio, where there is no point in buying the 1.4 version. Unfortunately, DXO has not tested the Sigma Art 1.4.

DxOMark comparison of the Nikon AF-S 50mm f/1.4G, AF 50mm f/1.4D and AF-S 50mm f/1.8G on a Nikon D810

Sadly, there are no tests yet of the Sigma 50mm 1.4 Art on Nikon cameras, but this link will give you a rough idea.

Share your own experience with 50mm lenses.

Next frame

Keep reading

All stories

Leica M Rangefinder: Why a Nikon Photographer Bought One

My thoughts and first-hand experience: why a photographer who has owned Nikon film and digital cameras of every class, plus some 40 Nikon lenses in all, suddenly bought a Leica and is completely delighted with it.

Comments 16

  1. Kaspars#16
    A very interesting article. It lets you look at and compare lenses that you probably will not end up buying all of :)
    It would be great if you made an article about macro lenses sometime.
  2. Antons#15
    Time to start shooting
  3. andre#14
    in the link there is a comparison Nikon 58mm F1.4 VS Nikon 58mm F1.2 Noct
  4. andrejs#13
    in the link interesting table with all 50mm
  5. Andrejs Zavadskis#12
    in the link another interesting comparison with 7 nikon lenses
  6. Tenisd#11
    Very good. How do all these compare to the Nikon 58mm?
  7. Andrejs#10
    Juri, you are that 1% of photographers who are especially demanding. My blog doesn't target people like you ;) Personally I'm not interested in those indicators that I can tweak in Lightroom. Also the 10 min video is just a quick overview.
  8. Jurka#9
    I expect you will delete the comment, as usual, but making a 10-minute review while focusing only on "sharpness, bokeh", come on, sorry, but you do not pay any attention at all to something like CONTRAST? Especially wide open on these fast lenses. Some are dull and need to be stopped down, others are already nicely contrasty right away. Then there is color rendering, warm/cool, that also differs significantly, as well as gray tone, the color, so to speak, dynamic range. Aberrations. In short, photograph something contrasty, for example black glossy text, and compare it, then you will understand what I am talking about!
  9. Andrejs Zavadskis#8
    write whether such a lens test gave you any conclusions? what else would you recommend to test lenses?
  10. juris#7
    generally prices are listed in the table next to each lens name
  11. fotogrāfs#6
    the more expensive the better
  12. PrimeFinance#5
    Useful article only would like to know a little more about prices too, because right now price is the most important :/
  13. Daniels#4
    Thanks, really very useful!
  14. Gints#3
    Thank you!
    Next I would gladly like to see a review of a 35mm.
  15. Ļoti Skaists#2
    hey, make a review of your home AUDIO system :) interested what you have there for sound at home! :*
  16. Reinis#1
    Good, thanks! Missing some picture with each one, to compare bokeh, sharpness etc.

Leave a comment

Questions, corrections and your own experience are welcome. Your e-mail is never published.

(email will not be published)
Links are not allowed in comments
two plus one =* (in words)