Image Rights and Privacy: What Photographers Should Know

The right to your own image is part of the right to privacy. I came across an article on how the law protects a person's image and have republished it here on my blog – every photographer should read it.

Wooden courtroom gavel resting on its sound block

Overview

Key facts

  • In this 2010 post, the blog republishes Latvian legal articles about a person's right to their own image and about when photographing someone infringes their privacy.
  • One of them summarises research by Anita Kovaļevska, who concludes that under ECHR case law, taking a picture of someone without consent does not in itself violate their privacy.
  • Whether a violation has occurred depends on where the picture was taken, whether it shows private life or a public event, and how it is used.
  • Under Latvia's Advertising Law, a natural person may not be shown in an advertisement without their consent.
  • Someone featured in an advert without consent can ask the National Radio and Television Council to halt it, or go to court and claim damages.

Image and Privacy

According to the author of the study, Mg. iur. Anita Kovaļevska – now head of the Human Rights Department at the Ombudsman's Office, and already a representative of the State Human Rights Office at the time she carried out the research – a person's right to their own image is one element of the right to privacy. Her analysis of the case law of the European Court of Human Rights shows that photographing or filming someone without consent cannot, on its own and without looking at the circumstances of the particular situation, be regarded as a restriction of the right to privacy. To determine whether someone's right to their own image, and with it the right to privacy, has been infringed, several circumstances have to be weighed. The study set out to identify which circumstances must be considered when a person is photographed or filmed and their image is used, so that their right to privacy is respected. It also tried to establish whether the right to privacy is effectively protected in Latvia. It is worth noting that the research was written in 2005 and presented to a wider audience a year later, yet its findings and conclusions are still relevant. In the study, the author takes a broad look at the right to privacy and at the principles developed in the case law of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR). She also examines the situation in Latvia: the legislation and the court rulings in such cases, of which there are still very few even now, more than a year later. In addition, the research includes a survey of 256 respondents on how they feel about being photographed or filmed and about images of them being used without their consent (on the whole, the respondents took a negative view both of any photographing or filming and of their images being used without their permission).  

No Single Definition of Privacy

Starting with a wider look at what the right to privacy actually covers, A. Kovaļevska concludes that a universal, all-embracing definition of it is practically impossible to give. The same point was made by ECHR judge Dīns Špīlmans (Dean Spielmann) during his visit to Latvia for this year's Lawyers' Day events: in a lecture on freedom of speech and the right to privacy, he stressed that the notion of private life is very wide and cannot be pinned down precisely. Still, according to D. Špīlmans, the ECHR holds that a person's image clearly forms part of their private life and must be protected from unjustified use that runs against the interests of the individual concerned. This raises a basic question: can the act of photographing or filming, whatever the circumstances, in itself violate someone's right to privacy? Must a person always give consent before being photographed or filmed? In search of an answer, A. Kovaļevska refers to the Court of Appeal of the United Kingdom, which found that taking someone's photograph without consent, as long as no physical force is used, does not violate that person's rights. ECHR case law likewise shows that photographing or filming a person without consent is not, by itself and without examining the circumstances of the case, a breach of the right to privacy. Having analysed specific cases brought before the ECHR, A. Kovaļevska concludes that in matters concerning a person's image the Court has examined the concrete circumstances, rather than finding a human rights violation simply because someone was photographed or filmed without permission.

What Decides Whether Rights Were Violated

To decide whether a person's right to their own image, and so their right to privacy, has been infringed, a number of factors therefore have to be assessed. The first is where the image was taken. Photographing or filming someone in a public place without their consent, for example, does not restrict their right to privacy. If, however, the person was at home at the time (whether the photographer shot from a distance or came inside), this violates the right to the inviolability of the home and thus, in a wider sense, the right to privacy. The author stresses, though, that places cannot always be clearly sorted into public ones and those that belong to the home (hotel rooms, boats and the like are examples). In Niemietz v. Germany, for instance, the ECHR accepted that the right to the inviolability of the home can extend to office premises. Clearly, the Court noted, a person may carry out work-related or commercial activities in their own home, just as work or business matters may be dealt with in an office. So it cannot be said with certainty whether, within the meaning of the European Convention on Human Rights, office premises are a public place or part of the home. It is worth adding that, in the ECHR's view, the way the concepts of "private life" and "home" are interpreted could lead to unequal treatment where a person's professional activities and private life cannot be told apart. For this reason, the author argues, the pitfalls of such a formal classification can only be avoided by asking whether, in the particular circumstances and whatever the formal status of the place where the photos or footage were taken, the person had reason to expect that what they were doing would stay private. If they did, photographing or filming them can breach their right to privacy even in a place that is formally public. The second factor is what the image shows: whether it depicts the person's private life or a public event or occasion. Photographing or filming someone who is taking part in a public event in a public place, and publishing those images, should not be treated as an invasion of privacy. In A. Kovaļevska's view, however, the line between public events and private life must not be drawn too narrowly, as if only what happens inside a person's home counted as private life. What matters most in telling private events from public occasions, she believes, is not where they take place but whether the wider public was invited to take part or was otherwise involved. Third, assessing a possible breach of the right to one's own image also means looking at how the image is used: whether it is meant for limited use or made available to society at large, which most often happens when it is printed in a newspaper or shown on television. On the other hand, publishing images in the press is closely tied to freedom of expression, guaranteed by Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights. That does not mean the press may publish anyone's image without consent. Moreover, where an image shows someone's private life, one has to consider whether publishing it adds anything to the discussion of matters of public importance. The author therefore takes the view that publishing an image of a person's private life (even a politician's) without consent is not acceptable if its only purpose is to satisfy the public's curiosity about that person's private life. A person's image may also be used for commercial purposes, where freedom of expression enjoys less protection. Commercial use of someone's image usually means advertising. The images used there have mostly been obtained lawfully and do not show events from the person's private life. That is why some argue that such cases are a matter not of the right to privacy but of commercial or property rights.

Too Little Case Law and Academic Writing

Turning to Latvia specifically, both its legislation and its case law, the author finds that the country's laws deal with a person's right to their own image only in very general terms. There are also too few court rulings and academic articles on the subject, although things have admittedly improved since the study was written: Inese Lībiņa, for example, has contributed to the analysis of the topic with publications, conference papers and a recently defended doctoral thesis. One should also bear in mind a judgment of the Constitutional Court which implies that, in cases concerning the use of a person's image, ECHR case law can be binding when human rights are applied in Latvia. Looking at the legislation, A. Kovaļevska notes that photographing, filming and the use of the resulting material are covered by several national laws. They set out, for instance, when police officers and other public officials are entitled to take photos or film in particular situations. During court hearings these matters are governed by the procedural laws. The use of images is also addressed in the Advertising Law: Article 4, part two, clause 4 prohibits showing, using or otherwise featuring a natural person in an advertisement without their consent. As for case law, the author refers to particular court judgments and examines them in more detail. A. Kovaļevska notes that the courts' approach to such cases is not yet consistent enough to be called established practice, but some conclusions can be drawn all the same. One is that in 2005 a person in Latvia could defend themselves against unauthorised use of their image if it harmed their honour and dignity. Now that a good deal of time has passed since the study was written, the first-instance ruling in Kristīne Dupāte's case against the magazine "Privātā Dzīve" (Private Life) gives hope that people can defend their rights not only when publishing their image has damaged their honour and dignity, but also when there has been a disproportionate intrusion into their private life.

Sannija Matule

The legal journal "Jurista Vārds" asks experts whether someone's image may be used in a commercial without their permission

A reader of "Jurista Vārds" spotted herself in a TV commercial: she appears in close-up, so she is easy to recognise, walking past Riga's Freedom Monument while talking on her mobile phone. The ad urges viewers to sign up with one of the local mobile operators, claiming its services are cheap and that the circle of customers will even grow. Yet the woman in the clip is not a customer of that operator, and nobody ever agreed her "appearance" in the ad with her – even though the commercial is being shown widely on several national TV channels. What is more, the woman is a public official, and Article 17 of the law "On Prevention of Conflict of Interest in State Official Activities" prohibits a state official from taking part in any form of advertising or letting their name be used for it, unless this falls within that official's duties. Some of her colleagues or superiors might well conclude that she has broken these restrictions. This situation raises several questions, which "Jurista Vārds" put to Anita Kovaļevska, head of the Human Rights Department at the Ombudsman's Office, and to experts from the Corruption Prevention and Combating Bureau (KNAB). Should the makers of the ad have agreed with this woman on the use of her image in a commercial (whether or not she is a public official)? A. Kovaļevska: This is governed by the Advertising Law. Under Article 4, part two, clause 4 of that law, an advertisement may not show, use or otherwise feature a natural person (whether as a private individual or as an official), or their property, without that person's consent. The makers of the ad therefore should not have used the woman's image without asking for her consent. Once the ad is already running in the media, can the person still prohibit the use of their image (and in effect stop the whole advertising "clip" from being shown)? A. Kovaļevska: Yes, the person is entitled to demand that the ad be taken off air. To do so, they need to apply to the National Radio and Television Council, which can check whether the advertisement complies with the law and, if it does not, ban its distribution. The person can also bring a civil claim in court and seek compensation for the harm already caused by broadcasting the ad. Can the woman herself be penalised for breaching the law "On Prevention of Conflict of Interest in State Official Activities"? KNAB: Part two of Article 17 of the law "On Prevention of Conflict of Interest in State Official Activities" defines what "advertising" means. In this case, it has to be public. If it was, a second criterion must also be considered: whether any remuneration was received for it. If not, the activity does not count as advertising within the meaning of this law. A breach of the law can therefore be found only where remuneration was received for the advertising. Given that, under the law "On Prevention of Conflict of Interest in State Official Activities", the woman may not accept gifts from the makers of the ad as compensation for the unauthorised use of her image in a commercial, is there any other way for her to obtain redress for it? KNAB: She can bring a civil claim against whoever created the advertisement. Source: Jurista Vārds, 24.07.2007, No. 30 (483), section "Questions. Answers"

Next frame

Keep reading

All stories

Comments

No comments yet — start the conversation.

Leave a comment

Questions, corrections and your own experience are welcome. Your e-mail is never published.

(email will not be published)
Links are not allowed in comments
one plus five =* (in words)