Leica M Rangefinder: Why a Nikon Photographer Bought One

My thoughts and first-hand experience: why a photographer who has owned Nikon film and digital cameras of every class, plus some 40 Nikon lenses in all, suddenly bought a Leica and is completely delighted with it.

Black Leica M camera with a large fast lens beside a Leica M book

Overview

Key facts

  • Written in 2016: Andrejs Zavadskis, who had shot Nikon for more than 14 years, explains what made him buy a Leica.
  • He was looking for a small full-frame camera for daily use with a very fast, sharp standard lens, something Nikon and Canon lenses did not give him.
  • A Voigtlander Bessa R3 film camera was his first taste of rangefinder shooting; after that he bought a Leica M (Typ 240), a Leica MP and a Noctilux-M 50mm f/0.95.
  • In his experience Leica RAW files need little editing, although the sensor performs worse at high ISO than those from Nikon, Sony or Canon.
  • Newcomers, he suggests, should begin with a film rangefinder: a Voigtlander Bessa R, a Zeiss Ikon or a second-hand Leica M6.

The Search for a Fast Lens

After more than 14 years with Nikon, why go for a Leica? From the very start of my career I have dreamed of fast lenses: the Canon 50mm 1.2 or 85mm 1.2, the manual-focus Nikon 50mm 1.2, and the one I still long for, the Nikkor 58mm f/1.2 Noct-NIKKOR. As the years went by I kept hoping that Nikon would at last make something special for people who love natural light. I bought lenses from every Nikon series, G, D and AIs, yet not one of them truly satisfied me. Wide open, no Nikon or Canon lens I have used has been properly sharp. The nearer a lens gets to f/1.0, the more sharpness, contrast, quality and detail fall away, while "haze" and aberrations creep in. It's like buying a powerful car only to find the power vanishes at high speed.

Photographer aiming a Leica M camera, reflected in a glass window


When the new Nikon 58mm f/1.4 arrived, I realised there was no longer any hope of getting a high-quality lens faster than f/1.4. My impression was that Nikon designs its optics with sports photographers in mind. The Sigma Art series pleasantly surprised me, and I own its 50mm, 35mm and 20 f 1.4 lenses. They are what I use for advertising work at f/1.4 as well, but they're no good for reportage, because the series is very slow, above all in the dark. I'm still pinning some hope on future Nikon lenses with FL (fluorite lens) and PF (Phase Fresnel) elements: they optically replace big, heavy glass elements, so lenses with the same specifications can be built lighter and smaller, which leaves room for faster designs. After waiting for years, I decided enough was enough! I began looking at what the market offered that could meet my particular wishes. One combination was still missing: the best fast standard lens on a full-frame sensor, in a camera small enough to carry every day. I wanted a camera for my everyday photography: family pictures, scenes I spot in the street, daily life, the people I meet and talk to. Something of real quality always at hand, in the pictures it makes as well as in the camera and lenses themselves. I kept searching until I discovered Leica.


What About Medium Format?

Who actually needs f/1.4 or f/1.0? One use is isolating the subject from its background. So why not go for medium format, if you can afford it? Logically, it would be the next step once you have mastered Nikon. At one point I did buy a Mamiya digital medium format system! It's excellent for studio work, portraits and nature, but the high-ISO quality was poor, the autofocus slow and inaccurate and even worse in low light, and the size of the camera didn't suit me. Digital medium format is fine for unhurried work where nothing has to happen fast. Nobody slings one over their shoulder for daily use. It's strictly a tool for slow work, and it costs about 50,000 euros. I had fun with it. It didn't satisfy me. I sold it.
Still, if you want ultimate quality and medium format in a body the size of a DSLR, Leica makes medium format cameras that are smaller than the competition: the Leica S system. I'd love to try it myself, and maybe I'd find what I'm after there, but I will have to save up for it first. So what about digital alternatives?

Leica is excellent, but it is also very expensive, so I started weighing up the alternatives. I settled on the Sony Alpha 7, a mirrorless digital camera. Physics gives mirrorless cameras several advantages. With no mirror mechanism, the lenses sit closer to the sensor plane, so they can be smaller and better, and manufacturers can build faster, higher-quality lenses than SLR designs allow. On top of that, adapters let you fit practically any lens to these cameras. Admittedly such lenses only work with manual focus, but the system still offers an incredible range of lens options.
The Sony Alpha 7 series is very good, with up-to-date sensors and the latest technology, but to my mind its autofocus falls behind monsters like the Nikon D5. Manual focusing on a Sony Alpha 7 is comfortable, yet only for posed pictures; for reportage, especially in poor light, focusing becomes a struggle. Among the lenses available for the Sony Alpha 7 series are the SLR Magic 50mm T0.95 Hyperprime Cine Lens, which comes very close to the quality of the Leica NOCTILUX, and the far cheaper Mitakon Speedmaster 50mm f/0.95 PRO. Either would fulfil the wish for a fast standard lens, although focusing would have to be done through LiveView.
So it might look as though a Sony body plus the right lens would do the job, but after digging deeper I decided this combination wouldn't give me even the basic quality and enjoyment I wanted from shooting. My aim was to find the very best the world had to offer in this area, so that I'd never need to look again. A cheaper substitute or any kind of compromise was not what I was after. And what about the Nikon Df? I was thrilled when the Nikon Df came out. It was exactly the kind of camera I had dreamed of carrying around for my personal photography, and for the odd work job when needed. Its greatest strength is that people take it for an old manual film camera, which makes it easier to shoot in the street, in big shops and in other public places. It's ideal for street art and travel. In all my time with it, nobody ever came up and told me to stop taking pictures. With my everyday Nikon D600, D750 or D800, on the other hand, shop security guards and hostile passers-by have stopped me from shooting. Those needless conflicts pull you away from the photography itself. A dream camera seemed to have arrived, but the lenses still fell short of the ideal. And holding a Nikon Df, you feel you're holding something plastic, even though it looks great from the outside. With time the silver finish wears off and grey plastic shows through. It isn't built to last.
Something else puzzles me. Put any film camera from the Nikon FM series, also full frame, next to a Nikon Df, and you have to wonder why Nikon couldn't fit the Df into an FM body. The Nikon FM is well made, classic, good-looking, durable and smaller than the Df. If a camera like that came on the market, I'd happily pay 2-3 times the price of a Df for it. I still hope that in a few years a Df2 will arrive that comes closer to what I want. Perhaps Nikon will release one for its 100th anniversary in 2017. The Df uses the excellent Nikon D4 sensor, but its autofocus module is taken from the budget-level D600. Put simply, you get a Ferrari with a thrifty 1.6 engine!

Nikon and Leica cameras compared

A Short History of Leica

Leica Camera logoSo what is Leica? To begin with, it is the only historic brand left from the earliest days of the camera. Its story is full of highs and lows, and you need to know a little of it to grasp what Leica is really about. In the 1910s cameras were big and heavy, used in studios or taken on trips for posed pictures from a tripod. Gradually smaller, portable cameras began to appear, but most were prototypes that vanished as quickly as they came. Leica had been making microscopes since 1849 and had a reputation as an excellent optics maker. Around 1913 it introduced the first rangefinder camera. A rangefinder is a viewfinder type in which the photographer composes and focuses through a separate window. With it Leica turned a new page in photographic history: people could take a small camera with them on their travels and record everything they saw. Many photographers had doubts about the 35mm film format, considering it far too small next to big studio cameras. Yet the point wasn't only quality but how widely the camera could be used, and thanks to Leica people saw the world in photographs, because a camera could now easily go to places it had never reached before. Only some 10 years later did Nikon and Canon copy Leica's rangefinders and offer cheaper versions. Around 1940 Canon and Nikon moved over to SLR cameras, which let the photographer see through the viewfinder exactly what the lens and the film see. It was a major breakthrough, with advantages and drawbacks alike. At about this time Leica developed autofocus, but, convinced that users would never want such a thing, sold the patent to the Japanese. From the very beginning Leica has led the field in build quality, and to this day Leica technicians receive 50-year-old cameras for servicing that need nothing more than oiling to work again, much as Nikon and Canon film cameras would.

From Pioneer to Luxury Brand

Over 100 years Leica has gone from a camera pioneer that opened up a new path to an exclusive brand that still builds its cameras around handwork and quality. Some would argue that computers and robots make lenses and cameras far better and more precisely. Yet take the Nikon 28mm f 1.4D and the Nikkor 58mm f/1.2 Noct-NIKKOR: both were made by hand, both remain legendary, and no modern Nikon lens has bettered the way they render. Nikon and Canon are driven by profit and make what sells, while exclusive products such as f/0.95 lenses don't pay off, since a lens like that ends up roughly 3 times bigger, heavier and pricier than an f1.4 one. Leica is the only maker that wrote one of the most important chapters in the history of how we take pictures today: it proved that a camera could be small and light, fit for everyday use and not only for professionals. Over the years its principles turned Leica into an exclusive brand, comparable to luxury wristwatches or exotic sports cars built in small numbers with special care and service. That is one reason a Leica costs so much. It was a joy to hold: I had never handled anything so well made. A Leica is a brand and a product you can pass on to your children. The company presents its cameras as a lasting investment that will serve for decades.
Leica's camera family tree:

Chart of Leica camera history

Trying a Rangefinder First

As I got to know Leica, it became clear that the M series suited me best. The Leica M is a rangefinder camera, and since rangefinders were new to me, I didn't want to spend big on a Leica straight away. Instead I bought a cheaper option: a Voigtlander Bessa R3 film camera. Some would point me to the Fuji x100, but cameras like that are hybrids, with an electronic viewfinder rather than a true rangefinder, or with a crop sensor. A real rangefinder is optical, not an LCD screen inside the viewfinder. Hybrids have poor viewfinders, can't focus really fast and are sluggish in the dark. So to at least try a rangefinder and find out whether I could live with one, I went for this inexpensive film option. After more than a year of shooting with it, I had genuinely grown fond of rangefinders. They make you see photography differently and open up new possibilities.

Leica and Voigtlander Bessa film rangefinders side by side

A rangefinder lets you see what lies beyond the edges of the frame, so you can compose precisely or wait for exactly the right moment. No mirror flips up to black out your view for a split second, so you stay in touch with the subject the whole time. You see the frame, and everything happening around it, all the time. There are downsides as well: big fast lenses intrude slightly into the frame, and parallax makes framing very close subjects a little tricky. With no mirror mechanism, both lenses and bodies are compact. The cameras are quiet and unobtrusive, which opens up new ways of shooting.
I began saving for a digital Leica. To make my pictures as different as possible from what I shot with Nikon gear, I had to get the most expensive lens, the Leica NOCTILUX-M 50mm f/0.95. People call it the dark armoured knight because of its unique light-gathering power: you can shoot handheld at night and still get wonderful frames.
I bought the Leica M (type 240) digital camera and the Leica MP 0.72 film camera, and the same lenses can be swapped between them. Leica film cameras also hold their value and are always in demand. I hope to pass these film cameras on to my children!

Leica MP film camera next to the digital Leica M

Living with the Leica M

The Leica M line combines Leica's classic rangefinder design with modern technology. The brand works hard to preserve classic values: the Leica M looks like a film camera on the outside but is modern inside. What won me over was its size, its quality and how quickly and accurately it can be focused in the dark. Focusing is manual, yet after some practice I found I could focus faster than with my Nikon D5, and in extreme conditions, even total darkness, it can still be done. Leica has one of the quietest shutters in the world, whereas the Sony Alpha 7 series irritated me by being as loud as an SLR. Comparing the Sony Alpha 7 with the Leica M, I came across another interesting fact. Many tests show that when the same Leica lens is mounted on a Sony and on a Leica, the Leica's pictures have fewer aberrations and better sharpness. The reason is that the Leica sensor is built specifically for Leica lenses, the two tuned to each other to produce a perfect image. Across the photo industry I have always found that a brand's own lenses perform much better on its cameras than lenses from other makers. That was one reason I decided against buying the Sony Alpha 7 with the SLR Magic 50mm f/0.95 Hyperprime Cine Lens as a cheaper alternative.

Leica M digital rangefinder camera


Leica is not the best camera in the world! What makes it special is that its maker cares about completely different things than Canon or Nikon do. Take the Leica NOCTILUX-M 50mm f/0.95: the fastest lens in the world that you can still buy new and that is still in production. It shows other manufacturers how a lens ought to be made, and that applies at f/0.95. Naturally it isn't flawless at f/0.95, but next to how any other lens renders at f/1.4, it stands head and shoulders above the rest. Nikon's fast lenses are a compromise between price, lens quality and image quality; Leica doesn't do compromises. It aims to give its users the very best.



Next to other cameras, a Leica is small, convenient and discreet to shoot with. Nobody pays you any attention. The shutter is so quiet that people barely catch the click and genuinely don't realise you're taking pictures, whereas with an SLR every click makes someone turn round. Optically, Leica lenses are superb, and their colour and tonal transitions are unique. Leica gear is one of those rare things worth keeping for a very long time. Most people will never grasp what this camera can do; they'll take it for an old film camera, while in fact it delivers a far better image than its competitors.

First Impressions

My first impressions? The camera may be small, but it is expensive, all the more so with the NOCTILUX-M 50mm f/0.95. It isn't as comfortable in the hand as a Nikon D5, though its grip feels a bit better than a Nikon Df's; the heavy 50mm f/0.95 is what makes it awkward. With smaller lenses you won't notice any weight or discomfort. The pictures have a character of their own, with a crispness and sense of depth reminiscent of medium format, and they need little editing. Nikon RAW files usually need a little freshening up before they look the way I want. With Leica RAW files, though, I started tweaking out of habit and then realised I had to reset everything, because it was all fine already. The crispness, sharpness and clarity come straight from the optics and the sensor. Now and then a file needs brightening or darkening, because Leica's auto exposure logic, or its centre-weighted metering, can be a little tricky to work around.
The one thing that disappoints me about the Leica, compared with Nikon, Sony or Canon, is how its sensor copes with high ISO. Other brands' sensors deliver cleaner images at high ISO and a wider dynamic range. Nikon files are forgiving, a lot can be rescued, and Nikon RAW tolerates big mistakes, especially from the Nikon D750; Leica's RAW files are far less forgiving and demand much more care with exposure. My instinct says Leica should bring out a new model, or refresh the current one with a more modern sensor, at the end of 2016 or early in 2017. A new model might be a little smaller, closer in size to the Leica film camera, and its newer sensor would open up even more possibilities.
Leica files hold white balance far better and make it easier to correct. To my mind, the Leica is ideal for posed outdoor pictures. It copes well with sunshine and even better with soft, diffused light, because the clarity of the sensor and optics brings out detail beautifully. I've shot weddings with a Leica too, though catching moments with manual focus takes some getting used to. There's a saying about Leica: when you're young you badly want one but can't afford it, and by the time you're older and can, your eyes are no longer sharp enough for a rangefinder :). That's no problem, though, since you can use liveview or buy an external digital viewfinder :).
I was also glad to find Adobe Lightroom bundled with the Leica camera.
Here are some everyday pictures I took with the Leica M:

Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 1 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 2 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 3 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 4 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 5 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 6 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 7 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 8 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 9 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 10 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 11 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 12 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 13 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 14 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 15 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 16 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 17 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 18 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 19 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 20 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 21 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 22 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 23 of 24 Everyday photo taken with the Leica M, 24 of 24

A Leica Store Close to Home

Without a Leica store in Latvia I probably wouldn't have bought one at all, because of servicing, support and access to lenses. So I'm delighted that there is finally a Leica store here too, where you can see every model and try out the lenses. The helpful staff will advise you and help you pick the model that suits you best. If you're looking for a present, I'd say the Leica Q is the best choice: perfect for everyday photography, and nobody could fail to like it. www.balticoptics.lv

Leica store in Riga

Another view of the Leica store in Riga

How to Get Started with Leica

If you'd like to try Leica but can't stretch to buying new, I'd suggest starting the way I did: with a film rangefinder. Begin with a Voigtlander Bessa R; next up in price is the Zeiss Ikon, and only after that the Leica M6, which you can find on eBay.
The M6 may well be the most popular Leica film camera, since it is the most affordable one. You can, of course, consider any other Leica model too. Here's a short guide to choosing a Leica film camera:

Guide to choosing a Leica film camera

If film isn't for you but you'd like something stylish with a Leica feel, you could begin with the Fujifilm X100 or the Fujifilm X-Pro2, though both, sadly, have crop sensors. For full frame, the Sony Cyber-shot DSC-RX1R II is an option, but I would still recommend the Leica Q. Neither of these two, unfortunately, is a rangefinder.
For a genuine, classic digital rangefinder that won't cost a fortune, my pick would be the Leica M-D. You could also hunt for a second-hand Leica M9 or Leica M8, although their sensors may disappoint you. Another route is a Sony Alpha 7 with adapters for Voigtlander, Zeiss or Leica lenses. For ultra-fast glass, the cheapest choice is the Mitakon Speedmaster 50mm f/0.95 PRO, but for now it only fits Sony.
There are plenty of options, and everyone will arrive at their own choice based on what they want and need. The main thing is to give it a try!


Leica Camera Latvia on Facebook

Own a Leica? Come and join our group

Next frame

Keep reading

All stories

Photo Gear Security: Preventing Theft, Fraud and Data Loss

Everyone knows how costly photo gear is. Saving up for a dream camera takes ages, never mind for great lenses. Bought piece by piece, a kit can add up to an impressive sum, and all of it often "fits" into one small camera bag.

Homo Novus Film Poster: Eight Separate Studio Portraits

For the “Homo Novus” film poster I shot every character on their own in the studio so the portraits could be assembled afterwards, and I used vintage Helios and Petzval lenses to bring in the feel of the 1930s.

Comments 12

  1. nacdejot#12
    This article really interested me, I just discovered my photographer skills. Photos are very beautiful!
  2. Leica fans#11
    Facts on why Leica is better than Canon and Nikon: https://gmpphoto.blogspot.com/2017/10/facts-and-figures-a…
  3. Tenisd#10
    Very good article, I like the photos too and the mood. How much do you photograph with film on MP 0.72 if you also have digital?
  4. Leica#9
    just need to read this to understand Leica's superiority http://www.overgaard.dk/leica-50mm-APO-Summicron-M-ASPH-f…
  5. Leica M 10#8
    Leica M10 finally a modern sensor, very good noise at high ISO and even sharper and clearer sensor. They say even better than Leica SL
  6. Askolds#7
    I would say it's ok! Nikon 135/2 AiS, 180/2.8 AiS and 50/1.2 AiS. it's a good value! I recommend
  7. rengefinder#6
    recommendation for cheap film rangefinder cameras
    Canon Canonet QL 17 GIII (~$100)
    Yashica Electro 35 GSN/GTN (~$50)
    Konica Hexar AF (~$400)
    Minolta Hi-Matic E (~$50)
    Contax G2 (~$400 - Body Only)
    Minolta CLE (~$300 - Body Only)
  8. fuji#5
    Fuji X100R is poor man's leica
  9. Martins#4
    Cool article, but a spellchecker would help. Plastic, rangefinder.. makes it hard to read such elementary mistakes!
  10. Andrejs Zavadskis#3
    Zeiss Otus is good, but to take the 1.4 version for Nikon, if there's Sigma ART with very very close performance but 4 times cheaper and with AF? Mitakon is good, but performance below SLR Magic and Leica. Mitakon still doesn't have a standard for FF for Canon or Nikon, for now only Mitakon Speedmaster 85mm f/1.2, but for Sony there is Mitakon Speedmaster 50mm f/0.95 PRO, but the tests aren't excellent. The goal was to take the absolute best available on the market among new lenses and never return to this question again.
  11. Uldis#2
    1. Did you try ZEISS OTUS for Nikon?
    2. Why for Sony only SLR Magic 50mm T0.95, but not say Zhongyi Mitakon?
    3. And Canon also has some bright lenses and even with AF?
  12. Ralfs K.#1
    Very good article, thanks Andrej! I have the same question - when looking for bright and quality optics, I've ended up from expensive G lenses to AiS manual ones. Really, really liked Nikon 135/2 AiS, 180/2.8 AiS and 50/1.2 AiS. However - something is missing for the image quality/clarity that I'd want... If I want digital and funds are limited - what Leica would you recommend? And - is it really worth paying 4-5kE, compared to Nikon FF and good Nikon optics?

Leave a comment

Questions, corrections and your own experience are welcome. Your e-mail is never published.

(email will not be published)
Links are not allowed in comments
two plus four =* (in words)