Nikon 85mm Lens Test: Sharpness and Bokeh of Seven Lenses
A hands-on comparison of several 85mm lenses for Nikon, including the Petzval and the Helios 40-2-H, both in Nikon mount. The main question is how they perform wide open: how sharp they are and what their bokeh looks like.

Overview
Key facts
- In 2015 Andrejs Zavadskis compared seven 85mm lenses on full-frame Nikon bodies, looking mainly at sharpness and bokeh at maximum aperture.
- The line-up: Nikon AF-S 85mm f/1.8 G and f/1.4 G, AF 85mm f/1.4 D, AiS f/1.4 and f/2.0, plus the Helios 40-2-H and the Petzval 85mm.
- The newer and more expensive the lens, the sharper it was wide open; the older designs and the Petzval produced the more characterful bokeh.
- None of the lenses offers fast focusing, sharpness and beautiful bokeh all at once: the G is the sharpest, the D focuses fastest and the AiS has the most pleasing bokeh.
- For professional work he suggests the AF-S f/1.8 G or f/1.4 G, with the Helios or Petzval only as a second lens for special effects.
The Classic Portrait Focal Length: 85mm
Once they outgrow the kit lens, most photographers buy a 50mm next. When the novelty of that wears off, the usual move is towards something wider or something longer. Nature and landscape shooters lean towards wider lenses, while portrait photographers start eyeing an 85mm or even longer glass. Here I compare seven 85mm lenses available in Nikon mount for full-frame sensors, with test shots included. What interests me most is how each lens behaves at full aperture: how sharp it is and how it renders the out-of-focus background – in other words, the bokeh. 
The Lenses Tested
|
|
AF-S Nikon 85mm f/1.8 G (€420) Launched in 2012 Dimensions: 80 x 73 mm Weight: 350 g Diaphragm blades: 7 Filter thread: 67 mm Closest focus: 80 cm + Lightweight, quiet, compact, affordable. - Rather tame bokeh, no f/1.4, slower AF, aberrations wide open at f/1.8 Score: 7+ Test shot Video |
|
|
AF-S Nikon 85mm f/1.4 G (€1300) Launched in 2010 Dimensions: 86 x 84 mm Weight: 595 g Diaphragm blades: 9 Filter thread: 77 mm Closest focus: 80 cm + f/1.4 - Tame bokeh, not perfectly sharp at f/1.4, slower AF, pricey, plenty of aberrations at f/1.4 Score: 8 Test shot Video |
|
|
AF Nikkor 85mm f/1.4 D (€1000) Made from 1995 to 2010 Dimensions: 79 x 74 mm Weight: 560 g Diaphragm blades: 9 Filter thread: 77 mm Closest focus: 85 cm + f/1.4, quick, perfect for reportage, nicer bokeh - not perfectly sharp at f/1.4, overpriced, new copies will soon vanish from the shops and prices will go up Score: 8 - Test shot Video |
|
|
AiS Nikkor 85mm f/1.4 (second-hand on eBay, €600) Made from 1981 to 2006 Dimensions: 72 x 80 mm Weight: 620 g Diaphragm blades: 9 Filter thread: 72 mm Closest focus: 85 cm + f/1.4, lovely bokeh, the most compact of the f/1.4 lenses, quiet, great for video - manual focus only, not perfectly sharp at f/1.4, heavy, hard to come by, getting pricier Score: 7 Test shot Video |
|
|
AiS Nikkor 85mm f/2.0 (second-hand on eBay, €180) Made from 1977 to 1995 Dimensions: 64 x 61 mm Weight: 312 g Diaphragm blades: 9 Filter thread: 52 mm Closest focus: 85 cm + lovely bokeh, the smallest and lightest lens in the test, great for video and for film cameras - manual focus only, no f/1.4 Score: 7 - Test shot Video |
|
|
Helios 40-2-H 85mm f/1.5 (brand new on eBay €450, or new €200 in Russia) Back in production since 2012, in Canon and Nikon mounts. Dimensions: 96 x 82 mm Weight: 880 g Diaphragm blades: 10 Filter thread: 67 mm Closest focus: 85 cm + lovely bokeh, f/1.5, aperture that adjusts smoothly, handy for video - the biggest and heaviest of the lot, manual focus only, and focusing by hand is clumsy Score: 6 - |
|
|
Petzval Lens 85mm f2.2 (new €550) Designed back in 1840; production resumed in 2013, now adapted to the 35mm format. Dimensions: 110 (with hood) x 70 mm Weight: 700 g Diaphragm blades: 1 Filter thread: 67 mm Closest focus: 100 cm + the crispest, most dramatic bokeh, the smallest and lightest of the lenses, great for video and for film cameras - manual focus only, no f/1.4, the aperture is set by slotting in a plate, looks odd without its lens hood, the softest lens wide open, made for centred compositions, fairly big and heavy. Score: 7 - Test shot Video |
How I Tested
A few words about the testing itself. Lenses are at their sharpest around f/4 and f/5.6. Open up to f/2.8 and they are still sharp, but as you approach f/1.4 both sharpness and contrast start to drop. Aberrations increase, and you lose contrast and detail. That is why any lens will be sharper at f/1.8 than at f/1.4. At f/1.4 nearly every lens shows some kind of haze or veil. Manufacturers work hard to remove or reduce it, but doing so pushes up the price and the size of the lens considerably. Sharpness at f/2.8 does not interest me much, since almost every lens is decent there. This test deliberately looks at maximum apertures, because that is where a manufacturer's skill and its latest advances in optics really show.
Sharpness Wide Open
Let's start with sharpness. Comparing lenses with different maximum apertures is not easy, but I will give it a go. The crops below come from my first test. You will see the word aberrations here – it refers to green and purple fringes along bright contours where they do not belong. Lenses with comparable maximum apertures share the same colour, and each one is scored out of 10. Feel free to download the test images, both the crops and the full frames shot on a Nikon D800e
The conclusion: the newer, more modern and more expensive the lens, the sharper the picture – yet there is still room for improvement, since wide open every lens shows a fair amount of aberration and less than perfect sharpness. The older Nikon lenses are visibly hazy at large apertures; the haze vanishes completely by f/4 on the old lenses and by f/2.8 on the new ones. It is worth noting that the Petzval is distinctly sharp in the centre, and because of the way it renders, it works best with centred compositions.
Bokeh Compared
Judging bokeh is subjective – it all comes down to personal taste. The term bokeh describes how a lens renders everything outside the zone of focus. The wider the aperture, the more striking the bokeh and the bigger the circles, but their shape and how crisp their edges are depends on the optical design. Bokeh can be harsh and crisp or, on the contrary, very soft, dreamy and hazy. I like it crisp and prominent myself, though that can also be distracting; it all depends on the subject and what you are shooting. Below I compare crops from the second test. On the test page you can download the full-resolution files, which makes the differences easier to see.
Sadly, as the results show, beautiful bokeh and sharpness simply do not go together. The older the lens, the lovelier and crisper its rendering of the out-of-focus areas.
During the test I noticed something odd: the angle of view of the AiS lenses differs from that of the Nikon D and G series. The AiS lenses are a touch more telephoto – in practice, their 85mm acts more like 90mm. That is why, when you look at the test shots, it can seem, at first glance, that their bokeh circles are bigger.
The Petzval Lens
The Petzval design dates back to 1840, when it was fitted to large-format view cameras. Its rendering became legendary thanks to the enchanting circular pattern of its bokeh. Petzval lenses grew rare and pricey: old ones go for around €1500 on eBay, and fitting them to a Nikon or Canon body was a hassle. Then, in 2013, I came across a Kickstarter campaign raising funds to put a Petzval lens for Nikon and Canon cameras into production:
The campaign attracted 3379 backers, who pledged a total of $1,396,149 to make it happen. You can buy the lens from www.lomography.com or from the Petzval project page.
As for how it performs: the Petzval draws beautifully in sunshine, but on overcast days, I leave it at home. I suggest using it for centred compositions, since only the middle of the frame is truly sharp and the bokeh circles swirl around it. A few of my own shots:
Manual focusing with this lens is quick and comfortable, although wide open it is sometimes hard to nail focus. To change the aperture you slot in plates with holes of different sizes, which is slower and less convenient. Its looks alone make people curious and amazed – a great way to strike up a conversation about photography. A black version is available too, at a higher price. I have never seen crisper bokeh than this lens produces.
A video in which I show how the bokeh shifts while focusing the Petzval wide open at f/2.2.
Helios 40-2
Helios 40-2 is a legend from the Soviet era. Back in film days it never became very popular: it was expensive, heavy and bulky, and nailing focus wide open was hard – whereas today, with digital, we can fire off several frames without worrying about filling the memory card. The lens is also famous for its bokeh and for its softness, or haze. Some see that haze as an ugly flaw that ruins the picture; others feel that this lack of sharpness lends a 3D depth, a lovely dreamy quality and a vintage feel to the photos. Personally I am not fond of the haze, but the bokeh it produces I like very much indeed. It is a very heavy and rather large lens, and the most awkward one to focus by hand. Film-makers will appreciate it, because the aperture closes smoothly rather than in clicks as on other lenses.
Take care if you buy a Helios with its original mount. A Helios with the original 42mm screw thread, fitted to a Nikon through an adapter, will not focus to infinity, or its focusing range will be limited in some other way, because the distance between lens and sensor changes. The Helios and Petzval used in this test both have a native Nikon mount.
Another thing: stopped down, the Helios 40-2 no longer draws nice round bokeh. With every step of the aperture the circles lose their roundness and turn more and more polygonal. Here is an example at f/2.8.
Sadly, I have not yet tried the Helios on a real shoot. As soon as I capture something worthwhile with it, I will post it here. Until then, see the test shots in the galleries.
My advice is to buy it new, directly from the maker's website shop.zenit-foto.ru
Nikon AiS Lenses
I am a big fan of Nikon's manual-focus AiS lenses – for their durability, their size, their bokeh and the way they render colour. They are very easy to focus by hand. On film cameras that is no problem at all, because they have a built-in focusing screen for manual focus. On digital cameras it is a little harder. I am thinking of fitting one of these focusing screens in my Nikon Df to make manual focusing even more comfortable. For my own everyday and family photos I happily reach for an AiS rather than a Nikon G or D lens.
Some Nikon AiS lenses are also a kind of investment, as their prices just keep going up – the legendary ones are becoming ever harder to find.
85mm Lenses for Video
If you are buying an 85mm lens for video, my conclusion is that you do not need top sharpness and image quality, while crisp, bold bokeh can only add to your creative options. Autofocus is practically useless for video, being noisy and imprecise. The newest lenses are also noisy when focused by hand, as the sound travels through the camera body. What surprised me was how smooth, quiet and pleasant the AiS lenses are to focus manually. In the first table, each lens has a "Video" link showing how it behaves when focused by hand and with the autofocus of a Nikon D750.
Here are my clips of each lens focusing, in autofocus and by hand: AF-S Nikon 85mm f/1.8 G, AF-S Nikon 85mm f/1.4 G, AF-S Nikkor 85mm f/1.4 D, AiS Nikkor 85mm f/1.4, AiS Nikkor 85mm f/2.0, Helios 40-2-H 85mm f/1.5, Petzval Lens 85mm f2.2.
What the Test Shows
The test illustrates nicely how Nikon lenses have evolved over 35 years. First came the AiS lenses, made from 1980 to 2000. Autofocus followed, bringing the Nikon D versions of 2000–2010. In recent years the Nikon G series has arrived, improved with special coatings (Nano Crystal Coat) and a quiet focusing motor (Silent Wave Motor) – that is how they compete on quality and convenience. With every generation the glass elements grow bigger, and, to keep the weight down, some of the metal parts are replaced with tough plastic. Remarkably, Nikon AiS lenses are so popular that they are still in production! At the moment Nikon makes 8 manual-focus lenses (sadly, no 85mm among them). Why are they still made? For one thing, I have noticed that their colours look a little more alive than those of modern lenses – more saturated, with slightly more contrast. Many people also love the way they render bokeh. Often it is the mood of a photo that people value, more than perfect sharpness: you can feel the mood even in a 10x15cm print, whereas sharpness only becomes apparent when you enlarge the image or print it big. On top of that, these lenses are smaller and will outlive autofocus lenses by far.
Today's Nikon lenses are sharper wide open, but sadly the aberrations are still there :(. Their bokeh also turns flat and unremarkable next to the old Nikon manual lenses, let alone the Helios and the Petzval. You have to work out for yourself what you really need: focusing speed, sharpness or bokeh? Not one of these lenses offers all three. The Nikon G series is very sharp, the D version very fast, and the AiS version gives the most beautiful bokeh. On the subject of speed, when I got my first G version lens, I was surprised to find it focused a little more slowly on Nikon's pro bodies. A Nikon G lens has its quiet focusing motor built into the lens, whereas with the D version the motor sits in the camera and drives the lens through a screw coupling, much like a drive shaft. So the more expensive the camera, the better its focusing motor. On a Nikon D lens you will find a coupling like this on the mount, and on the camera body a matching screw like this. It is these screws that drive focusing on D lenses. Many entry-level cameras have no such motor at all, so be careful when buying a D lens. Here is a video test that proves it, showing D lenses focusing faster on professional cameras. The Nikon 85mm f/1.8 D is regarded as the fastest-focusing 85mm.
That leaves one question to answer, namely: what is f/1.4 actually good for? Unless you shoot in dark interiors or at night, f/1.8 will serve you perfectly well. At 1.4 the background blurs a little more, and the camera finds focus more easily in low light, since more light reaches the AF sensors. The downsides of f/1.4 are cost, size and weight, plus extra editing time spent removing aberrations. Adobe Lightroom helps to deal with them, but cannot always get rid of them completely.
The DxOMark results show that the f/1.4 and f/1.8 Nikon G lenses are nearly identical: the f/1.4 resolves a little more detail but also shows a little more aberration. The Nikon D version still holds its own, and at larger apertures, on a camera with fewer than 23 megapixels, you will not notice any difference.

A couple of other options did not make it into this test, as I could not get hold of them. One is the excellent Samyang 85mm f/1.4, whose haze at f/1.4 closely resembles that of the Nikon G series – only without the aberrations. Examples can be seen here. A new Samyang costs about 270 euros, but bear in mind that it is manual focus only.
The other, firmly in the top high-end class, is the Carl Zeiss Apo Planar Otus 85mm f1.4 – sadly also manual, and priced at around €3500. It is a masterpiece of optics, but out of my reach. I imagine that for this money you get a superb lens combining excellent sharpness, beautiful bokeh and minimal aberrations – but that price hurts :)

Which 85mm Should You Buy?
Choosing an 85mm lens starts with a simple question, namely who you are and what you plan to shoot with it. If you are a professional working with high-resolution Nikon bodies (24, 36 MP or more) and making a living from it, quality comes first, and your choice is between the AF-S Nikon 85mm f/1.8 G and the AF-S Nikon 85mm f/1.4 G. Which one depends on your budget and your preferences. For a lot of studio work I would go for the 1.8. If money is no issue and you would like to play with f/1.4 now and then, take the 1.4.
Photojournalists and busy wedding photographers using a pro body should look at the AF Nikkor 85mm f/1.4 D or the AF Nikkor 85mm f/1.8 D. Stopped down, they are not much different from the G versions, but you will notice the faster focusing.
For amateurs and hobbyists who do not mind focusing by hand, one of the AiS lenses or the Samyang 85mm f/1.4 is worth considering.
The Helios and the Petzval are best as an extra lens for special effects, once you already own one of the Nikon 85mm lenses. They are not for everyday use, and I would not suggest either as your first 85mm.
Test Shots and Galleries
For this article I ran several tests with all 7 lenses, and if you would like to study the full-size files, here are links to the galleries:
Sharpness tests:
Sharpness test (vertical): short set full set
Horizontal bokeh test no. 1: short set full set
Horizontal bokeh test no. 2: short set full set
The full sets also include sharpness at infinity and at the minimum focusing distance.
Partway through the tests I had a thought, namely that the Helios was somewhat similar to the Petzval, since both are made by the same company, Zenit. My guess was that at the same aperture, they would give a similar picture – I was wrong. Here is a comparison of all 7 lenses at roughly f/2.0 each:
Equal-aperture test
Archive of test shots. Every test image is also kept at full resolution on my own server: 85mm lens test – full archive.
What has your experience with 85mm lenses been? Let me know.



























Otus 85/1.4 = 4.5k $
quality<=>speed<=>price
I liked the 85mm/1.2 (when I had it), very good sharpness even at 1.2 if you "nailed it", beautiful bokeh, but not especially snappy AF and chromatic aberrations
my opinion is that the 85mm ART series Sigma will outclass many of them
85/1.4 G https://www.flickr.com/photos/hhackbarth/15002464399/
Otus 85/1.4 https://www.flickr.com/photos/hhackbarth/15166213866/ Day and night. That guy has also tested the 85/1.8 G under the same conditions.