Nikon D3 vs D2Xs: Full-Frame vs Crop Sensor Compared
I bought a Nikon D3 a few months ago, and before parting with my Nikon D2Xs I ran a short test to see how a full-frame sensor really differs from a cropped one.

Overview
Key facts
- Written in 2008, this test by Andrejs Zavadskis puts the full-frame Nikon D3 up against the crop-sensor Nikon D2Xs to show what really changes when you move from DX to full frame.
- His noise test paired the Nikon D2Xs at ISO 400 with the D3 at ISO 1600 and found the D3 roughly three times cleaner.
- On the back, the D3 has a 3.0-inch display with 922,000 pixels, while the D2Xs offers 2.5 inches and 235,000 pixels.
- Further D3 strengths he lists: 51-point autofocus, sensitivity up to ISO 25600, twin Compact Flash slots and a shutter rated for 300,000 cycles.
- His verdict: a superb camera for reportage, although 12 megapixels fell short of what studio work required in 2008.
Getting Started
Nikon has just launched the D3, its first full-frame camera and a truly revolutionary one. With 12 megapixels it is an ideal tool for photojournalism, sport and weddings. This is not a review of how good the D3 is; instead it looks at what sets full-frame cameras apart from those with a crop sensor. A full-frame sensor measures 36 x 24 mm, whereas a crop sensor (Nikon DX) measures 23.7 x 15.7 mm. To some extent the same findings hold when the Canon 5D or the upcoming Canon 6D is set against the Canon 40D or Canon 400D, since their sensors are similar in size and characteristics. Wherever the Nikon D2x appears here, you can just as well read Nikon D200 or Nikon D300, because their noise and sensor performance are very much alike.ISO and Noise
The biggest difference, and the main reason a full-frame camera is worth buying, is the level of digital
noise, which is three times better than on crop-sensor cameras. For the test I switched off
all noise reduction on both bodies. I didn't compare the photos at identical
ISO values, since the D3 obviously produces less noise there,
but wanted to find the ISO settings at which the two cameras show a similar amount of noise.
My subject was a Mamiya camera, and I used a crop from the area where detail in the dark parts is easiest to see,
because noise is strongest in deep shadows. The Nikon D2Xs was fitted with a Nikon
28mm f/1.4 and the Nikon D3 with a Nikon 50mm f/1.4. I shot without a tripod, so sharpness can
vary.

In the first comparison the Nikon D2Xs at ISO 400 is set against the Nikon D3 at ISO 1600, both shown
as 100% crops.
(move the mouse pointer over the picture to switch)

The second pair puts the Nikon D2Xs at ISO 1600 next to the Nikon D3 at ISO 12800, again
as 100% crops.
(move the mouse pointer over the picture to switch)

It is fair to say that the Nikon D3 gives three times cleaner images than the Nikon D2Xs, and than
every other Nikon with a DX sensor.
LCD Screen
The D3 also won me over with its 3.0" display of 922,000
pixels, while the Nikon D2Xs has a 2.5" screen with 235,000 pixels. I photographed both
LCDs and compared 100% crops of those shots.

Below is the crop comparison; look closely at the fine detail. (move the mouse pointer
over the picture to switch)
![]()
What the D3 Does Better
- High image quality at high ISO, courtesy of the full-frame sensor.
- Superb LCD with a Live View mode
- Shallower depth of field than with a DX sensor.
- Sensitivity up to ISO 25600
- DX lenses can be used, though the image drops to 5-megapixel resolution.
- 14-bit A/D conversion with 12-channel readout
- Next-generation shutter rated for 300,000 cycles
- The new 51-point Multi-CAM3500FX autofocus module. After working with both bodies, I can tell that the D3 focuses better and more accurately.
- Autofocus fine-tuning to calibrate individual lenses
- Two Compact Flash slots: the second card can serve as a backup, take over recording when the first one is full, or store JPG while the first one stores RAW. UDMA is supported.
- HD video output over HDMI.
- Photos can be edited and cropped in the camera.
- The included charger takes 2 batteries at once.
Verdict
The Nikon D3 is a superb reportage camera: thanks to its full-frame sensor you can shoot at higher ISO and still get high-quality images. For today's studio work, however, 12 megapixels is not enough. Nikon is already developing and testing a new model, the Nikon D3x, which promises to be a dedicated studio camera with around 22 megapixels, though it won't manage as many frames per second. So if you are tempted by the D3 but spend most of your time in the studio, it pays to hold on until this autumn. The D3x will take on the Canon Mark III 1Ds. For now it also makes little sense to compare the Nikon D3 with the Canon 5D, because the 5D is a model more than 2 years old, and Canon plans to replace it with the Canon 6D this year.
Further Reading
The Nikon D3 compared with the Canon Mark III 1Ds:
read here
The Nikon D3 compared with the Canon 5D:
read here

I am terrrrribly interested, I have not yet seen any work from Latvians with this camera (though I also have not actively searched), I will give mine its first tries at Easter.