Nikon vs Canon: Lenses, Handling and Which to Choose

Canon or Nikon? Photographers argue about it endlessly, online and face to face, and Pentax and Olympus owners like to join in. Here is my honest answer to which brand is better, looking at lenses, handling, features and how each company treats its customers.

Nikon and Canon professional camera bodies facing each other in a boxing ring

Overview

Key facts

  • In this opinion piece from 2008, Andrejs Zavadskis weighs Canon against Nikon and finds that neither brand wins outright.
  • By his estimate, roughly 98% of professionals working in 35mm format use Canon or Nikon, and he regards Pentax and Olympus as amateur brands.
  • At the time of writing, Canon offered the broader lens range, while Nikon led on handling, flash features and compatibility with older lenses.
  • His advice is to try cameras in your own hands at a shop before buying, and to remember that the picture is made by the photographer rather than the camera.

An Old Rivalry

Canon and Nikon shooters quarrel the way BMW and Mercedes drivers always have. And just as Audi or Ford owners cut into the car debate, people with Pentax and Olympus cameras push their way into the photo arguments. You will find the same kind of pairing in almost any field: PC against Mac, women against men, strength against tenderness, and so on. But let's get back to photography.
Look at the professionals who work in 35mm format and you'll find that 98% of them shoot either Canon or Nikon. At sports events and press assignments, working shoulder to shoulder with other local pros, nobody has ever spotted an Olympus, Pentax, Sigma, Kodak or any other exotic creature – it is Canon or Nikon, without exception. Watch the photographers lined up at the Olympic Games and you see the same two brands. My point is that Canon and Nikon are, in my view and that of many colleagues, professional systems: they come with proper service, support, reliability and a complete product range. Pentax, Olympus and the rest are cameras for amateurs. One day, perhaps, a Pentax shooter with a serious backpack and a monopod will take his seat at the Olympics between the Canon and Nikon crowd, with an Olympus fan beside him swapping fast lenses – but that day is still some way off. So from here on I'll stick to Canon and Nikon.

So Which One Wins?

Which brand is better, then? The honest answer is neither. This contest has no winner now and never will, because both brands will always find people who want them.
The two makers offer cameras that match each other closely in specifications and price, differing only in details. Each has its strengths and weaknesses – nothing in this world is perfect, we can only keep moving towards perfection – and it turns out that Canon and Nikon have slightly different ideas of what that perfection looks like.

Where They Differ

Now let's go through the strong and weak points of each brand. None of the weak points is serious enough to rule a brand out; I see them as small irritations that will be fixed in time. Quite often, everything good about a camera is spoiled by a single detail – say, it just doesn't sit well in your hand – and that one small thing may turn out to be the biggest advantage or drawback for you personally.

Second-hand gear. Canon's popularity works in its favour: used Canon lenses are far easier to come by. The flip side is that when you buy a new L lens, plenty of people will want to borrow it for a try. Nikon owners are asked to lend out their gear much less often.

Lens range.
Canon clearly has the bigger and more impressive line-up. You can buy a 24mm f/1.4 or a 35mm f/1.4, while Nikon has stopped making its legendary 28mm f/1.4. Canon also sells f/1.2 and f/1.0 lenses, whereas at those apertures Nikon offers only manual-focus glass. Even so, many photographers feel Nikon optics are a notch better – the pictures they "draw" simply look nicer. Nikon is the top maker of microscopes, ahead even of Zeiss and Leitz, which says a lot about its experience with glass. Nikon also wins hearts with its mid-priced 85mm f/1.4, whereas Canon makes you choose between the inexpensive 85mm f/1.8 and the costly 85mm f/1.2. Nikon's greatest advantage is that old Nikon lenses fit any Nikon body, and their image quality very often beats that of modern autofocus lenses. You can browse a large selection of lenses for Nikon and Canon.

Features.
Put two models of the same class and price side by side, and the Nikon usually does more. It comes with extra functions and options that make it more convenient to use than its Canon counterpart, as any comparison on www.dpreview.com shows. Nikon's flash system is also more capable than Canon's (Wireless System, Commander mode).

Handling.
When it comes to controls, Nikon is ahead. Even Canon users admit that a single day is enough to learn a Nikon: the buttons sit where you would expect them and you find your way around by instinct, while a Canon (especially in the professional series) takes longer to get used to. Someone who has never held either brand will get the hang of a Nikon sooner, because its menus and controls are clearer and more logical. Nikon also avoids functions that need two buttons pressed together.

Company policy.
Canon has been spoiled by its chase for profit and ever higher sales figures, while Nikon pays more attention to what its customers need. You can see it in many details: the Nikon SB-800 flash ships with colour temperature filters and an extra battery compartment, things Canon owners have to hunt down separately. Canon also fairly often launches a camera that soon proves faulty, so freshly released bodies have to be sent back; Nikon, by contrast, tests its cameras for a long time before they reach the shops.

Bodies
. Some people point out that Nikon has no studio camera, meaning a high-megapixel model. Within the next six months Nikon will release the D3x, aimed more at studio work than at photojournalism, which is what the Nikon D3 is built for. The D3 itself took many by surprise. Canon, for its part, will soon bring out the Canon 6D, which should be able to rival the D3. All this simply shows that Nikon and Canon move forward in step, giving buyers cameras of the same class with only small differences.

My Advice

If you still can't make up your mind, my suggestion is simple: go to a shop and hold a few different cameras. You'll soon notice that some of them just don't suit your hand. Don't get lost in reviews or waste time on endless comparisons and test charts – buy sooner and get out shooting. You can't really pick the wrong one, since cameras in the same price bracket produce very similar results. Above all, remember that photos are made by photographers, not by cameras! A camera is only a tool, like the brush in a painter's hand... and no painter spends days arguing on forums about which company's brush to buy.

Next frame

Keep reading

All stories

Nikon 85mm Lens Test: Sharpness and Bokeh of Seven Lenses

A hands-on comparison of several 85mm lenses for Nikon, including the Petzval and the Helios 40-2-H, both in Nikon mount. The main question is how they perform wide open: how sharp they are and what their bokeh looks like.

Comments 7

  1. Andrejs Zavadskis#7
  2. fatals#6
    Thanks for the article, I did not know about the lens difference, it really makes me think about which one to buy next... I had been planning to buy a Canon 1 Mark III, but now I have to start thinking... Need to research more...:) At the moment I myself have a Canon D40 and I am quite satisfied...;) I think that all of this really goes into the same pot, and neither one nor the other will ever be the leader, at least not in the near future...;)
  3. Martins#5
    It is supposedly a camera comparison... but in reality it is justifying why still NIKON... :)!!!
  4. Fuzzy#4
    Similar statements a few years ago were made by Reinis (http://reinistraidas.lv/). Only not so broadly.

    A more picky person could easily argue against your arguments, but I myself have also come to like Nikons more... even because of the small design nuances (which are basically quite insignificant).
  5. LatFoto#3
    Well, that is approximately how it is ;-). I did not understand anything about politics though, but maybe it seems that way to someone.
  6. Raish#2
    I will quote myself from the pods.lv comments.

    Seven years ago everyone was shooting with Nikons, and now they will shoot with them again, that is clear. Just like any other kind of tech brand mania has cycles, cameras do too. For example, if someone now says AMD processors are better, then he is either conservative or looking to the future, but it has nothing to do with the real situation. I have been loyal to Nikon for three years already, although when this hobby started for me it was Canon time, but my dream about Nikon began seven years ago, when they were on top. This story can be compared to the fight between BMW and Mercedes in America, where for a while AUDI tries to squeeze in between, another time Lexus, aka Olympus, earlier Kodak, now possibly SONY. And all of you/we forget one thing - the investors and shareholders of these companies are the same people/companies, and the real battle is over the consumer who is constantly reaching for an alternative or an alternative to the alternative (- - = +). If there were one product in the market, none of these groups would be interested in it. If Nikon and Canon merged into one company, then surely they would crush all competitors like little flies. But then people would start looking for an alternative. These companies would lose a huge market share. Do you think Apple and Microsoft really compete that much? Yes, they compete. But these companies do not really care which product gets bought, because the whole hook lies in patents/chip suppliers/stock tickers and the spiral. Usually after such a stream of thoughts you just want to tell everyone to go to hell and buy a LOMO, but somebody makes that crap too and somebody owns it and you throw money into the common pot :)
  7. Papuass#1
    I myself use an entry-level Canon D400. The biggest minus is the grip. Small Japanese hands? I am also a little jealous of the relatively low price of the Nikon 70-200 F2.8. Canon users have to spend more for it. Overall I agree with the article, it is well written, even though you can feel the touch of a Nikon fan :)

Leave a comment

Questions, corrections and your own experience are welcome. Your e-mail is never published.

(email will not be published)
Links are not allowed in comments
one plus one =* (in words)