Nikon Z 24-70mm f/2.8 S II vs the Original: Hands-On Review

I tested the first Nikon Z 24-70mm f/2.8 S II to reach the Baltics: unboxing, the new internal zoom, near-silent VCM autofocus, and flare and sharpness comparisons with the 2019 original, backed by unedited Nikon Z8 JPEGs.

Nikon Z 24-70mm f/2.8 S II zoom lens with a Nikon Z8 camera

Overview

Key facts

  • Andrejs Zavadskis compares the first Nikon Z 24-70mm f/2.8 S II to arrive in the Baltics with the Z 24-70mm f/2.8 S released in 2019.
  • Fotoakadeemia, Nikon's centre in Estonia, supplied the lens; it was tested on a Nikon Z8, and the sample JPEGs are unedited.
  • The main changes are an internal zoom, Silky Swift VCM autofocus, 11 aperture blades, 77 mm filters and a 24 cm minimum focusing distance instead of 38 cm.
  • The new lens weighs about 120-130 g less, held its contrast when shooting into the sun and delivered clearly sharper corners at f/2.8.
  • He considers the upgrade worthwhile for filmmakers and for wedding, event, portrait and travel photographers who shoot at f/2.8.

First Copy in the Baltic States

A special delivery reached my studio: the brand-new Nikon NIKKOR Z 24-70mm f/2.8 S II, the first one in the Baltic states. It was sent by Fotoakadeemia, Nikon's centre in Estonia. René had only just got it and planned to keep it in the shop for customers to see, but I persuaded him to send it my way, since I was about to leave on a very special trip to Africa. In exchange, I promised him an honest review with real photos.

Below you'll find the unboxing, a look at what's new, a day out shooting with my Nikon Z8, and a direct comparison with the earlier Z 24-70mm f/2.8 S of 2019, which has been my lens for six years.

Video: my complete review of the Nikon Z 24-70mm f/2.8 S II, with the unboxing, the tests and the comparison.

Unedited Sample Photos

Every picture in the gallery below is straight out of the camera: Nikon Z8 JPEGs, unedited, unretouched and untouched in Lightroom. YouTube always compresses video, so I want you to be able to check sharpness, bokeh and contrast for yourself, on your own screen. The gallery lets you browse the shots, see the lens, aperture and shutter speed of each frame, and download the originals.

JPEGs from the Nikon Z8, with no editing. See the complete gallery on Files.fm and download the files in full resolution.

The Original Was Already a Leap Forward

I bought the first Z 24-70mm f/2.8 S as soon as it was released in 2019. Next to the DSLR zooms it was an enormous step up, most of all in sharpness at f/2.8, both in the centre and around it. Lenses usually lose sharpness as the aperture opens up, and manufacturers have spent years trying to make f/2.8 as crisp as f/4 or f/5.6.

My copy has seen plenty – deserts, rain, jungle, Burning Man. It's dark and grimy, yet it still works flawlessly. So for me the question was straightforward: is the new version genuinely better, or merely newer?

Out of the Box

The box itself was the first surprise: it is far smaller than the old one. The lens is also more compact when zoomed in, and a few new details catch your eye straight away:

  • The top display is gone. The previous lens had a little information panel; this one has none.
  • A window in the lens hood. Through a small hatch you can rotate a polariser or variable ND filter with the hood still in place.
  • An extra control button on the barrel that clicks clearly.
  • Less weight – about 120–130 g lighter than its predecessor.

The Biggest Change: Internal Zoom

The S II zooms internally: instead of the lens growing longer, the glass moves inside the barrel. It may sound minor, yet it makes a big difference:

  • Less dust gets in. A zoom that extends acts like a pump, drawing air – and dust with it – into the lens every time you zoom. Dust is visible inside my old lens. Taking a lens apart to clean it isn't a good idea, as it's nearly impossible to put it back together exactly the way it left the factory.
  • Tougher in harsh conditions. An extended front barrel is easily knocked. Years of use have left a little play in the front section of my old lens, and a front element that is even slightly out of line can silently cost you image quality. The new construction is far sturdier.
  • Better for gimbals and video. Because the balance doesn't change across the zoom range, there's no need to rebalance the gimbal after zooming.
  • Always the same length – the lens stays as compact as the old one in its retracted state.

Optical Design and Coatings

On paper, the previous lens uses 17 elements in 15 groups, Nano Crystal and ARNEO coatings and 9 aperture blades. The S II is built from 14 elements in 10 groups – among them ED and aspherical elements and a big double-sided aspherical element up front – with Meso Amorphous, ARNEO and fluorine coatings and 11 rounded aperture blades.

Why make such a fuss about coatings? Outside you might only notice them when shooting towards the sun, but at events, concerts, discos, birthday parties and arenas, lights constantly shine right into the lens. Good coatings keep ghosting, flare and that milky drop in contrast out of your pictures.

Shooting Into the Sun: Flare Test

From the same spot, I aimed each lens directly at a bright sun:

  • Old lens, f/2.8: obvious flare and a hazy, milky drop in contrast.
  • New lens, f/2.8: contrast holds up, and the flare is so faint I had to search for it.
  • f/22: both produce a larger, sunstar-like flare, yet the new lens still retains its contrast. If you want flare as a creative effect, simply stop down to f/22.

Expect the same gap at night, when LEDs and spotlights strike the lens from all sorts of angles.

Quicker, Near-Silent Autofocus

Focusing on the S II is handled by Nikon's new Silky Swift VCM (voice coil motor) system. To me this marks the beginning of a new generation: sooner or later the other S-line zooms, such as the 70-200, will get these motors too.

  • Noise: with a microphone placed right by the lens, you can clearly hear the old version racking from minimum focus to infinity. The new one was practically inaudible.
  • Speed: it feels roughly twice as quick and far more responsive. Turn it manually to the closest distance, switch to AF, and it locks onto people instantly.
  • Tracking: I filmed my daughter on a swing – a tough test for any AF system. In video mode it stayed on her face throughout, without jumping off.

Videographers get even more: an internal zoom, less focus breathing and calmer, quieter focusing. If you shoot video, this lens was built for you.

Smaller Filters, Closer Focus

  • Filter thread: 77 mm rather than 82 mm. Quality ND, polarising and UV filters cost more in bigger sizes, so this saves you money.
  • Closest focus: 24 cm at the wide end, against 38 cm on the old lens. At 24 mm I can focus on the lens cap when it is almost touching the lens – a bit like a wide-angle macro. Even at 70 mm I can get much closer.

That opens up many new compositions for details, food, products, small animals, insects and tight portraits.

Out and About With the Nikon Z8

My family and I took a walk around Riga, with the Z8, both lenses and a tripod in tow. I photographed portraits, cityscapes, close-ups, food, cars and street life, mostly at f/2.8 – if I'm paying for an f/2.8 lens, that's the aperture I'll use most, especially on a camera that offers very fast shutter speeds even in strong sunshine. And if you have never been: Riga is a beautiful city, best visited on a sunny summer day.

  • Corners at f/2.8: very crisp – perhaps a hair softer than the centre, but outstanding for this aperture.
  • Bokeh: smooth and gentle rather than busy. With 11 blades, out-of-focus highlights remain round even at f/7.1 and f/8.
  • Close-ups: metal details, a coffee cup, skin texture and sunglasses shot at minimum distance all came out very sharp.
  • Food: shooting from the same spot, the old lens reached its limit, whereas the S II got nearly to macro.
  • Birds and children: the AF had no trouble with birds in the shade or kids at play.

Tripod Comparison: New Versus Old

To compare them fairly, I left the camera on a tripod with identical settings and swapped only the lens. The results:

  • 70 mm, f/2.8: the old lens was clearly softer – I went through several frames to make sure focus wasn't the problem. Towards the edges the gap was enormous; the new lens keeps lines and contrast crisp.
  • 24 mm, f/2.8: in the centre they are very close, with the new one a little sharper. In the corners the S II clearly wins: more contrast, less smearing and less chromatic aberration. A sign that was blurred with the old lens was readable with the new one.
  • About 36 mm, f/2.8: the S II is better in the middle and distinctly better in the corners.
  • f/22: there is virtually no difference between the two.
  • Bokeh near the frame edges: the new lens renders a few more “cat’s eye” shapes; in the centre, both give almost circular highlights.
  • Vignetting and distortion: comparable, and both are simple to correct with the Lightroom lens profile.

The main gain isn't in the dead centre but in the area surrounding it. Lenses used wide open were once sharp in the middle and soft towards the edges; now we are approaching images that are sharp across the whole frame.

Is the Upgrade Worth It for You?

  • Filmmakers – without a doubt: internal zoom, silent AF, reduced breathing and a gimbal balance that stays put.
  • Wedding, event and reportage photographers – yes. If you photograph groups at f/2.8 and need edge-to-edge sharpness, or battle stage lighting and backlight, you'll see a real difference.
  • Travel and street photographers – a lighter, non-extending lens is easier to carry all day and less vulnerable hanging from your shoulder.
  • Portrait and detail photographers – softer bokeh, sharper edges and a far shorter close-focus distance.
  • Owners of the old lens who mostly shoot at f/5.6–f/8 – you'll notice little difference, and the lens you have may be perfectly adequate.

Verdict

I'm delighted to have this lens, and it's coming with me on my Africa trip. If you work professionally – weddings, portraits, children, reportage or video – and like shooting at f/2.8, I believe the Nikon Z 24-70mm f/2.8 S II justifies the upgrade.

But don't rely on my opinion alone: look through the unedited JPEGs in the gallery above and decide for yourself. Should I also compare it with my other Nikon zooms, the 24-70mm f/4 and the 24-120mm f/4? Tell me in the comments.

Andrejs Zavadskis — photographer · Portfolio · The review on YouTube · Full-size JPEGs on Files.fm

Next frame

Keep reading

All stories

Nikon 85mm Lens Test: Sharpness and Bokeh of Seven Lenses

A hands-on comparison of several 85mm lenses for Nikon, including the Petzval and the Helios 40-2-H, both in Nikon mount. The main question is how they perform wide open: how sharp they are and what their bokeh looks like.

Leica M3 Photo Wins People’s Choice in Leica Store Contest

A black-and-white picture of my Leica M3 cradled in my wife’s grandmother’s hands took 3rd place – the People’s Choice Award, with 193 likes – in the “MONOHROMS” contest run by Leica Camera Latvia, and went on show in the offic...

Comments

No comments yet — start the conversation.

Leave a comment

Questions, corrections and your own experience are welcome. Your e-mail is never published.

(email will not be published)
Links are not allowed in comments
five plus one =* (in words)