Radio Flash Triggers Compared: Budget, Bowens, PocketWizard

A look at the best-known radio triggers from different makers: budget Chinese units versus the pricey Bowens Pulsar and PocketWizard. If the term is new to you, a radio trigger is a transmitter and receiver pair that fires your flashes with no cables attached.

Bowens Pulsar radio trigger for studio flashes

Overview

Key facts

  • In 2008 Andrejs Zavadskis compared wireless radio triggers for studio flashes: budget Chinese units, Bowens Pulsar and PocketWizard.
  • The cheap Chinese triggers sold for about €14–21 on eBay in 2008, yet radio interference disrupted roughly 50% of his shoots outside the studio.
  • Bowens Pulsar units worked dependably with studio flashes, although one batch fired twice when paired with his Nikon SB-800.
  • The PocketWizard Plus II and MultiMAX ranked among the most dependable, with a range of 500 metres, though owners reported antennas breaking.
  • His advice: PocketWizard for regular location work, budget triggers when money is short and many flashes have to be fired.

Overview

 

From Sync Cords to Radio

In the beginning there was the cable: a simple sync cord that fired the flash at the moment the shutter opened. Its weakness is the cord itself, which restricts how far you can move from both the subject and the flash. Worse still, it makes firing several flashes difficult. In theory you could build splitters, but that is impractical and turns the studio into a tangle of cables. The next step forward was the optical slave, built into some flashes and also sold as a separate add-on "catcher". It does away with the cord, but the slave has to see the triggering flash directly (or its reflection), which limits where your lights can go. Wireless infrared triggers have the same restriction. The newest generation is radio triggers, or transmitters, which let you place flashes behind walls and much farther away than cables or optical slaves allow. Still, not every radio transmitter and receiver performs equally well, so let's review the most common ones.

Budget Chinese Triggers

Inexpensive Chinese radio flash trigger setThe cheapest triggers, and the easiest for anyone to get, are the budget models from China. The local shop mdfoto.lv charges about €57 for them, while on eBay a full set with one transmitter and one receiver goes for around €14–21. Search eBay for "Wireless Flash Remote Trigger". They come in several models, sometimes with different brand stickers, yet they all behave the same. I have tested 3 different versions myself, and every one let me down. Reliability is the main issue: there simply isn't any. In the studio they behave, but the trouble begins on location, in unfamiliar interiors or outdoors. Being the cheapest option, they have no shielding against radio interference, and stray signals in the air are enough to set them off. Mobile phones, microwave ovens or other devices nearby make them act unpredictably. They may suddenly start firing the flash over and over, or stop responding entirely. At times only every third press works. In my experience, about 50% of my shoots outside the studio ran into problems like these. My own studio had no radio interference, and there they worked perfectly. Range is about 30 metres.

Bowens Pulsar

Bowens Pulsar radio transceiverBowens Pulsar triggers are far more dependable: they ignore stray radio signals and fire every time. The catch is a price that hurts once you need to fit three or more flashes with them. At mdfoto a starter kit costs about €327, whereas bhphotovideo sells it for about €199. There is no separate transmitter or receiver: each unit can do either job. Range is about 50 metres. They are not flawless, though: depending on the production batch, they may not cooperate smoothly with on-camera flashes. I bought them twice from the same shop, and one batch makes my Nikon SB-800 fire twice in a row. The same oddity affects Canon flashes if you are unlucky with your batch. Others have run into this too, as these discussions show: Bowens forum and photo.net.  Fixing it means modifying the electronics, which I haven't tried. My other batch, on the other hand, works flawlessly, and with studio flashes they are reliable in any case. Another weak point is the PC sync socket, which is flimsy and has no locking or screw-in mechanism. Sometimes a trigger fails to respond simply because of a poor contact that needs a nudge.

PocketWizard

PocketWizard radio flash trigger PocketWizard triggers are some of the most dependable around. They come in two versions, Plus II and MultiMAX, which differ in both price and features. The Plus II syncs with flashes at 1/250–1/500 of a second, while the MultiMAX manages 1/500–1/1000, which matters for high-end studio cameras, though it costs even more. At bhphotovideo a single Plus II transceiver is about €142 and a single MultiMAX about €213. A starter pair of Plus II units therefore comes to about €284, and two MultiMAX units to about €426 (buying the same kit locally would cost around €570–710). PocketWizards reach up to 500 metres. Their main weakness is build quality: they are not very robust, and many owners complain that the antennas eventually break.

Other Options

These were the best-known radio triggers, but plenty of other brands exist:
www.microsyncdigital.com – the tiniest radio triggers.
www.studioflash.co.uk – a range of Chinese models
Flash Waves Radio Trigger – seems handy for on-camera flashes
If you rely on something else that works well, please share your review in the comments.

Conclusion

If you regularly work outdoors or in unfamiliar locations with one or two flashes, it pays to save up for the more reliable PocketWizard triggers. If money is tight and you need several flashes, the cheap "made in China" triggers are still worth buying: they remove many of the hassles of cables and optical sync, even if they bring surprises of their own. Speaking from experience, I started with the cheap ones myself and was glad I had them, because they beat having nothing at all. That counts even more when a shoot calls for 7-8 flashes, since paying around €1,140 for a radio sync system alone is a costly luxury.

Next frame

Keep reading

All stories

Comments 16

  1. Eliss#16
    can someone recommend where in Riga can I buy triggers?
  2. nuakin#15
  3. grāfs#14
    AlienBees all equipment can be ordered to Latvia directly from them only they add additional 10%. They use UPS Worldwide Saver for delivery. For Europe they provide warranty but postage costs must be paid by yourself.
  4. Jānis#13
    sb-600 with these can be triggered? or only from the camera flash?
  5. Krišs#12
    Thanks for the article, of course, but Andrej, being a professional in photo matters, please do not write "zibspuldze" incorrectly. In Latvian, "spuldze" is written with the short vowel.
  6. Andrejs Zavadskis#11
    You did not read to the end, where it says "Others". The intermediaries will send it, sure, but what will they do when it breaks? And intermediaries add their own markup, so it will be more advantageous to buy from locals on the spot...
  7. LatFoto#10
    I'm not saying that they are good. Just wanted to say that there are still alternatives not just these 3 mentioned. To Europe can be sent without problems - there are intermediary companies that provide these services.
  8. Andrejs Zavadskis#9
    daini, they don't send anything to Europe! also how can you say they are good before you have tried. by descriptions and parameters everyone is good, but in practice it's completely different
  9. LatFoto#8
    There are still various triggers on the market, for example this recently released:

    http://latfoto.lv/fototehnikas-jaunumi/14-fototehnikas-ja…

    Costs 70 and 60 USD. Operating range is not half a kilometer though, but still good.
  10. Iewar1jumZ#7
    Thanks for the article. Was interesting, at least my knowledge expanded a bit. :)
  11. Martinsh#6
    I use the Chinese "miracle" Cactus v2 - I trigger external flashes with it. What is interesting is that with a Canon flash it quite often fires spontaneously, but with Nikon SB 24/26 it works normally, succeeding on average 7 times out of 10, though that also depends on whether you were lucky with a good set.
  12. Andrejs Zavadskis#5
    yeah I read. but unfortunately with studio lights still have to wait when they introduce such a system...
  13. Papuass#4
    Did you read about RadioPopper? http://radiopopper.com/
  14. Andrejs Zavadskis#3
    and nikon SU-800 wasn't dissected because we're talking about studio light triggering, where su unfortunately works only with nikon sb series flashes.
  15. Andrejs Zavadskis#2
    it's comparable to infrared triggers. there will be many situations when distance won't work and there won't be direct line of sight. Also outside in real sun there will be more problems. still if you buy it I recommend considering buying another sb-800 instead. it will be the same, but will have additional flash
  16. Ingus#1
    Maybe a stupid question, but if we're talking about Nikon, why isn't the option with SU-800 reviewed (http://www.kenrockwell.com/nikon/su800.htm) ?

    Just soon planning to buy something from this series and then one eye is on specifically SU-800. Maybe you have some experience with it?

Leave a comment

Questions, corrections and your own experience are welcome. Your e-mail is never published.

(email will not be published)
Links are not allowed in comments
five plus four =* (in words)