TIO Photoshot Questions: Editing, RAW and Nikon vs Canon

The dairy company Riga Piena Kombinats held a TIO photoshot event and picked me as its photographer. Here are the visitors' questions I answered there, on photo editing, RAW files and Nikon vs Canon.

Blue Riga Piena Kombinats dairy gift box with a milk splash design

Overview

Key facts

  • At the TIO photoshot event held by the dairy company Riga Piena Kombinats, Andrejs Zavadskis was the chosen photographer and answered visitors' questions about photography.
  • He taught himself photo editing through trial and error and online tutorials; his main tool is Adobe Lightroom, with Photoshop used now and then.
  • RAW, he explains, is a way of saving files rather than a size: it stores far more image information than JPG, which is the better choice for everyday photos of family and friends.
  • For pictures that look washed out on a computer, he suggests checking them on another monitor or in another viewing program, or having the screen calibrated by professionals.
  • Asked about Canon versus Nikon, he restates his opinion that neither brand comes out clearly on top.

At the Event


At the TIO photoshot event, visitors were free to ask anything about photography, and it was my job to answer. Luckily there weren't 1000 questions, just a handful, so I could give each of them a thorough reply.

A big thank-you to the Base team and to Riga Piena Kombinats!!!
 

Visitors' Questions

Did you teach yourself photo editing by trial and error, or did you also take courses? And which programs do you use, if you don't mind me asking?

Yes, everything I know comes from experimenting on my own pictures and from material I found online. My tip: go to google.com and search for whatever interests you together with the word "tutorials" – "photoshop tutorials", for instance. That way you'll find a huge number of them.
Most of my work is done in Adobe Lightroom, and now and then I use Adobe Photoshop.

Hi. I own a Canon Powershot G9. Why do my pictures look bright on the camera screen, but dull and pale once I copy them to the computer? And what is RAW size?

How pictures appear on a computer depends on the monitor as well as on the computer's settings. Borrow a friend's monitor to check whether yours is to blame. If the photos look just the same on the second screen, the cause lies in the operating system or in the program you view them with. Try opening the files in different software, or have your monitor calibrated by professionals.
RAW isn't a size at all – it's one of the ways a camera can save a photo. Depending on the camera model there are several of them: JPG, TIFF, RAW and others. A RAW file holds much more information about the image than a JPG, which is why it fills your memory card far faster. It is mostly chosen by people who edit their photos afterwards in graphics software and want as much of the recorded image data as possible to work with. For pictures of family and friends, stick with JPG.

Nikon or Canon – which camera is better?

The eternal battle between BMW and Mercedes owners has a twin in the battle between Canon and Nikon photographers. And as Audi, Ford and others butt into the car feud, Pentax and Olympus users barge into the camera one. Similar pairs exist in plenty of other areas – PC versus Mac, woman versus man, strength versus tenderness and so on. Now to photography in particular.
Among professionals using the 35mm format, 98% shoot Canon or Nikon. Standing among fellow pros at sports games or news events, nobody has ever seen an Olympus, Pentax, Sigma, Kodak or some other beast – only Canons and Nikons, nothing else. The row of photographers at the Olympic Games tells the same story: Canon and Nikon only. What I mean is that I, like many others, consider Canon and Nikon professional cameras, because the service, support, reliability and range of products behind them match that status. Pentax, Olympus and similar brands are amateur cameras. Perhaps a day will come when a Pentax user with a decent backpack and a monopod sits down between the Canon and Nikon photographers at the world Olympics, while an Olympus fan right next to him changes fast lenses – but that will take time. That is why the rest of this answer covers only Canon and Nikon.

So which one is better? Truthfully, neither is the best. This fight has no winner and never will, because each brand has its own buyers.
Both companies make cameras that are nearly identical in specs and price, with only small differences, since each has its pros and cons – and as we all know, nothing is perfect; we can only strive for perfection. Canon and Nikon, though, seem to picture that ideal a little differently.

Let's look more closely at the advantages and disadvantages of each. The disadvantages aren't so bad that they should put you off a brand; to me they are minor annoyances that will improve with time. Frequently, though, all of a camera's strengths are overshadowed by something small, such as an uncomfortable grip, and that kind of detail may matter more to you than anything else, for better or worse.

Canon benefits from being so popular: buying second-hand Canon lenses is much easier. That popularity also means that once you own a new L lens, lots of people will ask to try it. Nikon users live a quieter life when it comes to lending gear out.

Canon's lens line-up is undoubtedly wider and more impressive. It includes lenses such as the 24mm f/1.4 and the 35mm f/1.4, whereas Nikon's legendary 28mm f/1.4 is no longer made. Canon has f/1.2 and f/1.0 lenses, while Nikon makes lenses this fast only with manual focus. Many people believe, however, that Nikon's glass is slightly better – as they put it, a Nikon lens "draws more pleasantly". (Nikon is the leader in microscope production, ahead of even Zeiss and Leitz, which only underlines its experience in making optics.) Nikon impresses with the mid-range 85mm f/1.4, while Canon offers either the budget 85mm f/1.8 or the pricey 85mm f/1.2. Nikon's biggest plus is that older Nikon lenses fit on any Nikon camera, and very often their quality is better than that of modern autofocus lenses. It's worth browsing the many lenses available for both Nikon and Canon.

In the same class and price range, Nikon models offer more functions than Canon ones. Nikon builds in extra features and options that make its cameras more convenient than the Canon equivalents – a model comparison on www.dpreview.com makes this very clear. Nikon's flash system, with its Wireless System and Commander mode, is also more versatile than Canon's.

Nikon is easier to operate. Even Canon fans admit you can learn a Nikon in a day, since every button is in a logical place and you intuitively know where to find things, while a Canon – the pro series in particular – takes longer to master. A beginner who has never used either brand will learn a Nikon more quickly thanks to its clearer, better-organised controls. Nikon doesn't rely on two-button combinations either.

Chasing profit and sales volume has spoiled Canon, whereas Nikon takes its customers' interests more seriously. This shows in lots of ways – for example, the Nikon SB-800 flash is supplied with colour temperature filters and an additional battery compartment, which Canon owners have to go and find for themselves. Every so often Canon puts out a camera that soon turns out to have a defect, and the brand-new bodies must be returned, while Nikon spends a long time testing its cameras before they go on sale.

You may hear that Nikon lacks a studio camera, that is, a high-resolution body. Within half a year Nikon will launch the D3x, designed for studio work rather than for photojournalism like the Nikon D3 – a camera that surprised a lot of people. Canon will soon follow with its Canon 6D, which will be able to take on the D3. It just goes to show that Nikon and Canon keep pace with each other and please buyers with cameras of the same class that differ only in small ways.

If for whatever reason you can't decide, just visit a shop and pick up several cameras. You'll find that some of them simply weren't made for your hand. Don't bury yourself in reviews or burn time on pointless comparisons and tests – buy quickly and start taking pictures. You can't go wrong, because cameras in the same price range deliver very similar results. And the most important thing to remember: it is the photographer who makes the photo, not the camera – and that photographer is YOU! A camera is merely a tool, like a brush in a painter's hand... and you'll never find a painter spending days on a forum debating which brand of brush to buy.

Good luck choosing!

Next frame

Keep reading

All stories

Photography Questions Answered on Video: Send Yours In

I'm planning an open day at my studio soon, when anyone can drop by to chat about photography and life, get to know me and say whatever is on their mind. Before that, I'd like to record a short video answering your questions.

Comments 5

  1. Verdi#5
    After the article it sounds more like Nikon patriotism than the advantages of Canon and Nikon. I disagree about the button functionality. When they gave me a Nikon, I could not understand anything there, what to press where in order to find what I needed. Canon is much simpler.
  2. LatFoto#4
    Are these old answers or what? They presented the Canon 7D today, and Nikon already has the D3X too, apparently.
  3. mirtins#3
    Are these not old answers?
  4. Artūrs#2
    In the second question, it definitely should have been noted that RAW is a data format with unprocessed data, and to get the familiar *.JPG image that can be sent to friends, printed or posted on the internet, a RAW converter is needed - a program (there are many of them, for example the camera manufacturer's software: Nikon Capture NX or Canon Digital Photo Professional).

    Your answer to the third question, Andrej, turned out long (and worthy of a Nikon fan), but I think that if the person asking is a beginner, then you did not need to talk so much about primes (lenses with fixed focal length, for example 24mm 1.4, 85mm 1.4). By the way, the Nikon D3X is already on sale (the camera price is approximately 3500 Ls).

    Here is a link about the upcoming Canon D6: http://forum.freemarket.ua/showthread.php?t=3045

    :)
  5. Artūrs#1
    In the second question, it definitely should have been noted that RAW is a data format with unprocessed data, and to get the familiar *.JPG image that can be sent to friends, printed or posted on the internet, a RAW converter is needed - a program (there are many of them, for example the camera manufacturer's software: Nikon Capture NX or Canon Digital Photo Professional).

    Your answer to the third question, Andrej, turned out long (and worthy of a Nikon fan), but I think that if the person asking is a beginner, then you did not need to talk so much about primes (lenses with fixed focal length, for example 24mm 1.4, 85mm 1.4). By the way, the Nikon D3X is already on sale (the camera price is approximately 3500 Ls).

    Here is a link about the upcoming Canon D6: http://forum.freemarket.ua/showthread.php?t=3045

    :)

Leave a comment

Questions, corrections and your own experience are welcome. Your e-mail is never published.

(email will not be published)
Links are not allowed in comments
two plus two =* (in words)